Sag Harbor, NY housing market
Typical home value
$2.31M
▲ 5.8% 1 yr
Typical rent
$49,398/mo
▲ 10.1% 1 yr
Gross rent yield
25.6%
U.S. 6.3%
5-year home value change
+34%
U.S. +20%
Key takeaways
- 1The typical home in Sag Harbor is worth $2,314,656, up 5.8% over the past year and up 34% over five years.
- 2Typical rent is $49,398 a month (+10.1% YoY), a gross rent yield of 25.6% (above the New York, NY metro's 5.8%).
- 3With 20% down at 7.32%, principal and interest on the typical home is about $12,720/mo, $36,678 less than typical rent.
- 4Zillow forecasts the New York, NY metro's home values to change +2.8% over the next 12 months.
Market temperature (New York, NY metro)
Neutral market
Buyer'sNeutralSeller's
Zillow Market Heat Index: 55/100, #79 hottest of 546 metros. Below 44 favors buyers; above 55 favors sellers.
Home values and rent
Source: Zillow Research (ZHVI, ZORI and market activity data).
How Sag Harbor compares
| Measure | Sag Harbor | New York, NY metro | United States |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical home value | $2,314,656 | $730,949 | $366,157 |
| Home value, 1-yr change | +5.8% | +4.9% | +1.2% |
| Typical rent | $49,398 | $3,546 | $1,932 |
| Rent, 1-yr change | +10.1% | +4.2% | +2.7% |
| Gross rent yield | 25.6% | 5.8% | 6.3% |
| Price-to-rent ratio | 3.9 | 17.2 | 15.8 |
| Mortgage P&I, typical home | $12,720 | $4,017 | $2,012 |
Run the numbers
Rental property calculator
Cash flow on a typical Sag Harbor rental, pre-filled.
Rent vs buy in Sag Harbor
Which costs less over the years you'll stay.
Mortgage calculator
Monthly payment on a $2.31M home.
Landlord in New York? See New York deposit, late fee and notice rules.
Other cities in the New York, NY metro
New York, NY
$826K home$4,089 rent
▲ 4.3% 1 yr
Newark, NJ
$480K home$2,111 rent
▼ 1.0% 1 yr
Jersey City, NJ
$657K home$3,101 rent
▲ 0.4% 1 yr
Yonkers, NY
$702K home$2,765 rent
▲ 7.3% 1 yr
Paterson, NJ
$541K home$1,889 rent
▲ 5.0% 1 yr
Elizabeth, NJ
$552K home$2,230 rent
▲ 2.9% 1 yr
Toms River, NJ
$463K home$3,026 rent
▲ 3.8% 1 yr
Edison, NJ
$636K home$2,787 rent
▲ 2.2% 1 yr
City figures are Zillow's typical home value (ZHVI) and observed rent (ZORI). Gross yield is before expenses. Data refreshed Oct 26, 2026.